2007
The Oresteia, by David Johnston

2006
The Standards of Decency Project
The Most Wonderful Love, by Matthew Freeman
Paradise, by David Foley

2005
Busted Jesus Comix, by David Johnston

2004
The Great Escape, by Matthew Freeman
The Americans, by Matthew Freeman

2003
Busted Jesus Comix + 3 More Plays!, by David Johnston
A Bush Carol, by David Johnston and Stephen Speights

2002
Kingfish, by Marlene Mayer
Dimly Perceived Threats to the System, by Jon Klein

2001
Roots in Water, by Richard Nelson
Psychopathia Sexualis, by John Patrick Shanley
Eileen O’Connor Is Contagious, by Eileen O’Connor

2000
Wanda’s Visit, by Christopher Durang
The Author’s Voice, by Richard Greenberg
Nebraska, by Keith Reddin
TB or Not TB, by Eileen O’Connor

1999
Brilliant Traces, by Cindy Lou Johnson